What should young people learn when AI can do half the work?
Some governments are making AI mandatory in school. Others are pulling it out. The research shows that everything depends on how the tool is designed.
A 12-year-old today will be 25 in 2039. That is when they will start looking for work.
In November 2025, the McKinsey Global Institute estimated that today's technology could, in theory, automate about 57% of work hours in the United States. That number measures what the machine can do. How companies will use it is still an open question.
This puts a hard question to schools. What happens on the day nobody needs to learn math anymore? In La Presse, the columnist Marie-France Bazzo asks it in her own way:
Young people have already decided in practice. According to the OECD's PISA 2025, about 86% of 15-year-olds in OECD countries use AI for their schoolwork.
Governments have already chosen, and they went in opposite directions.
China is teaching AI to everyone. In April 2026, five Chinese ministries launched a national plan that adds AI to school curricula across the country. In Beijing, every primary and secondary student already takes at least eight hours of AI classes a year.
Estonia is shaping the tool. Since January 2026, about 20,000 students in 154 of the country's 156 upper secondary schools have had access to an AI app in Estonian. The app is designed to guide students with questions. Teacher training started in August 2025. The University of Tartu is measuring the effects with 9,000 students, and results are expected at the end of 2026.
South Korea pulled back. In March 2025, it introduced AI digital textbooks in English, math and computer science. In the first semester, 37% of schools had adopted them. On August 4, 2025, the National Assembly downgraded them to simple educational materials. When school resumed in September, 19% were still using them.
New York is protecting minors. On October 28, 2026, Governor Kathy Hochul signed bill S9051B. Starting January 1, 2027, companies may no longer offer minors AI companions that claim to be human, flatter the user, or encourage secrecy and isolation. They will also have to verify their users' age.
These choices have a precedent. In September 2023, UNESCO already asked governments to consider a minimum age of 13 for AI use in the classroom. In Canada, Adam Dubé, a professor in McGill University's Faculty of Education, wants to go further. He proposes banning AI for students until they graduate. In his words:
The research measures an effect that depends on the tool.
In Turkey, AI helped with practice and hurt on the exam. Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania followed nearly 1,000 high school math students. One group practised with a version of ChatGPT that had no guardrails. These students did 48% better on their exercises than the control group. On the exam without AI, they scored 17% lower. Another group used a tutor version that gives hints. On the exam, that group scored about the same as the control group.
In Nigeria, an AI tutor sped up learning. In 2024, the World Bank tested six weeks of AI tutoring in an after-school program in Benin City. The students' gains equal nearly two years of typical learning. The program outperformed 80% of the education interventions evaluated in developing countries.
At Harvard, a tutor designed by teachers doubled the gains. Physics professors designed an AI tutor that guides students step by step. In a controlled trial with 194 students, published in June 2025 in Scientific Reports, this tutor more than doubled learning gains compared with an active-learning class. The authors note that the trial covered introductory material.
PISA sees the same pattern at scale. Students who ask AI to summarize, search or write score about 20 points lower in science, close to a full year of school. Students who use it every week to learn score about the same as those who do not use it. The OECD notes that these are correlations.
The real divide is how the tool is designed.
These studies tell the same story. An AI that gives the answer does the student's work for them. The student improves on the exercise and falls behind on the exam. An AI designed to make students think can instead speed up their learning.
So the math question takes on a new meaning. Students who hand their problems to the machine lose ground. Students whom the machine guides may learn faster than before.
The debate between banning and teaching hides another question. Who decides how the tools students use are designed? The most widespread tools are built by companies for the general public. Estonia chose an app designed for learning. New York sets limits by law. Adam Dubé even sees a ban as a way to push companies to build tools that develop the ability to learn.
Schools keep three missions that a machine fulfills poorly.
Raising citizens who can debate. Mélissa Canseliet, a specialist in neuroscience and cyberpsychology, points to what is at stake for democracy. According to Université Laval's NETendances survey, published in February 2025, only one in ten Quebec internet users feels they know AI well. A population that understands AI poorly will struggle to debate the choices it imposes. Canseliet wants to:
Building common ground. Marie-France Bazzo fears a new kind of dropout: students who graduate without knowing how to learn. For her, school must teach what technology cannot do:
It must also bring young people together around shared knowledge, in a culture that is more and more fragmented.
Offering the presence of an adult. Pascale Sirard, director general of Collège Bois-de-Boulogne, finds her answer in Albert Camus. When he received the Nobel Prize in 1957, Camus thanked his schoolteacher, Louis Germain:
For Pascale Sirard, a teacher's role lies in presence and in the relationship. She sums it up this way:
What decisions do leaders face?
These facts leave governments and school systems with three decisions.
- Who designs the students' tools? A government can let students use general-public tools. It can block access, as New York does for some uses. It can also require tools designed for learning, as Estonia does.
- What should a diploma guarantee? A student can now hand in perfect work without having learned anything. Assessments will have to measure what students can do on their own.
- What is left to teach? The machine calculates, summarizes and writes. Reasoning, judgment and connection with others remain the student's work.
Today's 12-year-olds are already living through this change. The adults who make the decisions now have to help them understand the story they are living.
- Why AI won't take your job: McKinsey on agents, robots and skill partnerships, Fortune, 2025-11
- PISA 2025: How 15-Year-Olds Use AI Chatbots for Schoolwork, Business Standard, 2026-09
- IA et apprentissage : ce que PISA 2025 nous invite à examiner, École branchée, 2026-10
- China aims to build an AI literacy system, gouvernement de la Chine, 2026-04
- Factsheet AI Leap, e-Estonia, 2026-04
- Research and Reviews, TI-Hüpe (AI Leap), 2026
- AI Textbooks Downgraded to Educational Materials as National Assembly Passes Bill, Asia Economy, 2025-08
- AI-powered textbooks fail to make the grade in South Korea, Junhyup Kwon, Rest of World, 2025-10-15 (ajoutée en v2)
- New York Enacts AI Chatbot Safeguards for Minors, Holland & Knight, 2026-11
- UNESCO calls for regulations on AI use in schools, ONU Info, 2023-09
- Without Guardrails, Generative AI Can Harm Education, Knowledge at Wharton, 2024-08
- From chalkboards to chatbots: Transforming learning in Nigeria, Banque mondiale, 2025-01
- AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning, Scientific Reports, 2025-06
- Une majorité d'internautes a de la difficulté à reconnaître l'intervention de l'intelligence artificielle dans la vie quotidienne, Université Laval, 2025-02
- Les agents d'IA devraient-ils être interdits aux ados ?, Alain McKenna, La Presse, 2026-10-27
- Pendant que l'IA avance, les citoyens restent à la traîne, Mélissa Canseliet, La Presse, 2025-11-23
- Ne décrochons pas de l'humanité, Marie-France Bazzo, La Presse, 2026-08-24
- Ce que demain exigera de nous, Pascale Sirard, La Presse, 2026-08-25